The IRS blocking journalism groups from becoming nonprofits. Data caps that throttle ability to livestream video of breaking news events. Journalists and news organizations need to understand the new media and technology policy issues that are shaping their future, and how to weigh in on them, as many did when the online piracy bills SOPA/PIPA were introduced. This session will bring together journalists and policy advocates to dive into current debates and spark a discussion about how they can be both covered and confronted.
Resrouces
Reminder about engaging brain before keyboard – important point for everyone, not just dissidents in other countries:
Question: Should Twitter be able to hand over sensitive info about dissidents? #ojr #onapolicy to.pbs.org/Sel57O
— Brian Frank (@frankreporting) September 22, 2012
.@digiphile: Correction: Not to say dissidents shouldn’t use social media, but be safe. i.e. use phone you can toss/wipe. #ojr #onapolicy
— Brian Frank (@frankreporting) September 22, 2012
More session notes as sketches:
Illustrated notes from #ONAPolicy ow.ly/i/Xtio – thanks to the panel @dangillmor @digiphile @lizlebron1 and @jcsterns #ONA12
— Graham Clark (@hello_thankyou) September 22, 2012
Referenced earlier in this session – Trans Pacific Partnership Agreement
Riffing on FreePress declaration on access and some broadband companies (indirectly news orgs) that lobby to prohibit municipalities from providing broadband:
.@kegill: U.S. decided rural needs phones/power, even provided loans. Now saying not provide broadband flies in face of that #ojr #onapolicy
— Brian Frank (@frankreporting) September 22, 2012
To @kegill‘s point, internet freedom requires access. See FreePress’s declaration: bit.ly/LslgpD #ojr #onapolicy
— Brian Frank (@frankreporting) September 22, 2012
At #ONApolicy, @jcstearns reminds us there is still a huge digital divide in the US. #ONA12 twitter.com/susie_c/status…
— Susie Cagle (@susie_c) September 22, 2012
@digiphile celebrates Brazil #foia law, in argentina we still waiting #onapolicy so media & hacktivism started moving
— Momi Peralta (@momiperalta) September 22, 2012
Always – technology will outpace the policy. – @digiphile #onapolicy
— Heather Blanchard (@poplifegirl) September 22, 2012
Awesome – sketch notes:
Awesome RT @susie_c Sketches from great conversation at #ONApolicy feat. @digiphile @dangillmor @lizlebron1 #ONA12 twitter.com/susie_c/status…
— Marika (@marikalynch) September 22, 2012
Audience Q from net neutrality – domestically and abroad
@Digiphile -> FCC rules “excepted” mobile – they have to decide how to deal with peak demand. Can Public Knowledge force the FCC hand re voice v data. “Reasonable network management” has been part of the Internet since the very beginning. Telemedicine – can make a case for prioritizing that data. It gets tricky when you have a monopoly in broadband providers — Comcast and Netflix as competitors is classic example. Watch actions that these companies take.
Copyright @dangillmor : “First amendment should not be subject to Terms of Service” #onapolicy #ona12
— Mario Tedeschini-Lal (@tedeschini) September 22, 2012
Dan reminds the group that Hollywood has been in Washington a lot longer than tech – which explains current copyright law (in part). This is not a party-line issue, according to Gillmor.
.@dangillmor: what we do as journalists is quote, remix. Remixing is in trouble. We must understand copyright law. #ojr #onapolicy
— Brian Frank (@frankreporting) September 22, 2012
@dangillmor: As journalists, “we remix things. Copyright law really frowns on remixing.” #ONAPolicy
— Chris Amico (@eyeseast) September 22, 2012
Policy battles are often positioned as between two giant corporate sectors. Josh suggests that framing leaves out issues of democracy and public journalism.
Owners of media outlets have role in reshaping media policies. #ona12 #onapolicy
— hani (@hanihazaimeh) September 22, 2012
News organizations that lobby against their reporter’s interests – CJR: cjr.org/swing_states_p… #onapolicy #ona12
— Kathy E Gill (@kegill) September 22, 2012
I think that tech is divided in these issues, entertainment is united, tech isn’t #onapolicy
— Heather Blanchard (@poplifegirl) September 22, 2012
Alex pointing out that lots of corporate money flows on information issues. Tech companies are getting into the game.
We can analyze much of this data -> http://opensecrets.org
Josh is now talking about TV news companies lobbying against transparency (NAB protesting FTC rule to make political ad info accessible on the web)
San Francisco Public Press finally got 501(c)3 status – they have been waiting for 32 months. Normally it takes six months or less. @jcstearns
.@jcstearns: IRS has decided not sure how to classify journalism, whether classify as education in nonprofit model. #ojr #ona12 #onapolicy
— Brian Frank (@frankreporting) September 22, 2012
Alex @digiphile articulating broadcast media company lack of reporting on SOPA
Here’s the @brianstelter story on SOPA/PIPA coverage that @digiphile referred to: nyti.ms/woe2Yh #onapolicy #ona12
— Daniel Victor (@bydanielvictor) September 22, 2012
To the extent we place info on Twitter, Facebook, Google etc – we lose control. Then there is government censorship – two examples: Wikileaks (credit card contributions blocked) and hip-hop site taken down by the US gov’t for a year, then returned to owner with no apology. @DanGillmor
Panel pix:
#ONApolicy session panelists @dangillmor @lizlebron1 @digiphile Moderator @jcstearns twitter.com/kegill/status/…
— Kathy E Gill (@kegill) September 22, 2012
A reminder that a company’s taking stands may be in direct conflict with their journalists – @dangillmor
“The public square of our internet being encroached upon by companies that want to create walled gardens.” – @digiphile #ONApolicy
— Marie K. Shanahan (@mariekshan) September 22, 2012
Alex: can someone who has committed an act of journalism be protected by a shield law?
Q from @jcstearns : What’s one open gov policy journalists should be aware of: @digiphile -> shield law and credentialing journalists
O’Reilly Media participated in internet blackout data. @digiphile is the resident journalist, so he has a somewhat different role #ONAPolicy
— Chris Amico (@eyeseast) September 22, 2012
The session hashtag has changed from #beyondSOPA to #ONApolicy
CISPA/SOPA #ONA12policy session underway Ballroom B ona12.journalists.org/sessions/cispa… #beyondSOPA @digiphile @lizlebron1 @dangillmor #ONA12
— Kathy E Gill (@kegill) September 22, 2012

Session shout-outs: